Blog Discussion Group Ten
Blog post due at 11:55pm on April 9 and comment due at 11:55pm on April 12.
Iran
- In what ways can the global context influence
- What parallels can be drawn to the Bolshevik Revolution in
- Can religious identity sustain secular state institutions and serve developmental goals?
2. What parallels can be drawn to the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia and the Islamic Revolution in Iran?
ReplyDeleteThe Bolshevik Revolution in Russia and Iranian Revolution had similar causes. Both had a lot to do with foreign forces. For Russia, WWI thrust them into conflict when Germany declared war on them. After that, Russia had many occurrences over territory and relations with other European countries and some Asian counties, such as Japan. For Iran, a kick start was America’s involvement with a military coup. Due to America’s actions, the Shaw came to power and essentially became a “puppet” much to the dismay of their people. Both countries had leaders fighting for power over several decades and intense opposition. In result of their revolutions, they became considerably hostile countries and followed themes of Marxism.
Can religious identity sustain secular state institutions and serve developmental goals?
ReplyDeleteI do not think that religious identity can sustain secular state institutions within one state or governance, especially in such a strict theocracy as Iran carries. Iran struggles with diplomatic relations with foreign countries because they are philosophically against the ideas of western civilization, which has made international growth and diversity non existent. Iran prescribes only to what Iran wants and believes which is a deep devotion to their religious calling, which leaves little room for secular ideas. The acceptance of secular ideas is a very serious offense for Muslim religion, so therefore the theocracy will not allow secular institutions to thrive. Theocracies such as Iran do not prescribe to many worldly motivations other than what is needed for survival. So again, I do not think that a religious identity such as Iran can sustain secular institutions.
https://www.britannica.com/place/Iran/Religion
I agree with your claim on Iran being against western civilization. But I feel Iran is just acting in to the the claim of human rights and globalization theory . They are not willing to embark on Realtionships with other countries because of their beliefs on international politics and they just are acting in their rights of being able to dictate their own government beliefs
Delete1. In what ways can the global context influence Iran’s development from this point forward?
ReplyDeleteThe global climate can affect Iran's development in multiple ways. If sanctions are placed on Iran it can lead to slower development due to the sanctions hurting Iran's economy. Also any military action Iran decides to take would pull resources towards their armed forces and away from other things that would have otherwise helped Iran develop further economically. Economic might is very important in a country's development. The more Iran can focus on itself and not have to worry about outside hostility the faster they can develop.
https://www.heritage.org/index/country/iran
This is Tommy btw
DeleteTommy, this is a truly well-written post. Even if Iran focused on itself entirely, I do not believe they have what it takes to grow. Advanced technology and outsider business is needed to develop.
DeleteThe comment above is by Robert Ellis. sorry
DeleteIn what ways can the global context influence Iran’s development from this point forward?
ReplyDeleteThe influence global context can have on Iran's development could be revolutionary. The spread of westernizationn throught the world has changed the future for many countries. Globalizationn has already made its moark on Iran with gender equality and women appearing more in positions of authority. This is accompanied by western clothinng, music, movies, etc. If Iran were to become more globalized, the result could mean more development especially if the strict islamic regime is loosened. To grow and develop, a country needs to welcome outside technology and business and that can, in return, boost the economy of Iran. The current governmennt in Iran tends to be problematic when attempting to integrate with other countries. For the global context to influence Iran's development, something in the government would have to change. This change would most likely be the large influence of the islamic laws, yet there is not much chance of Iran dissociating from their strong religious views.
https://yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/globalization-and-middle-east-part-one
https://sites.google.com/a/iastate.edu/iranian-research-project/entry-1
It seems as if you are well read on this topic, Robert. Almost as if you had done a presentation on Iran within the last few hours. Anyway, as always a good and thorough explanation of the question at hand! Sad that the semester is almost over and will no longer have the privilege of reading your well thought out posts.
DeleteThis unknown post is by Robert Ellis.
ReplyDeleteIn what ways can the global context influence Iran’s development from this point forward?
ReplyDeleteAs seen in the presentation by the group tonight, sanctions have had a significant negative impact on the economy of Iran. Over the years, Iran has experienced much influence from other countries that are attempting to benefit from their resources. However, given their past, Iranians still see greatness in their future. They view their current status as difficult but temporary and the quest for nuclear energy is viewed as a key to their modern development. For many ordinary Iranians, it is an issue of sovereignty. As they modernize, they want to avoid any further dependence on the outside world. It will be a difficult task but the global community can work to try and repair the fractured relationships with Iran and continually search for common ground and perhaps develop agreements that will benefit everyone involved.
https://iranprimer.usip.org/resource/challenge-iran